The Great Cheese Heist of Cheese-ia
The Great Cheese Heist of Cheese-ia
On the pastoral plane of Innistrad's forgotten cousin—the idyllic Cheese-ia—a perfectly ordinary cheese merchant has died under suspicious circumstances, leaving behind a will that gifts his prized collection of enchanted cheeses to a deserving adventurer. However, three separate factions (a pompous merchant's guild, a cultish order of goat herders, and a band of sentient rats) have all claimed pieces of the inheritance, sparking a comedic three-way race to steal, negotiate, and outwit each other for the magical dairy delicacies.
Read Aloud
You arrive in the pastoral hamlet of Cheddarwood, where the air smells overwhelmingly of aged dairy, burnt herbs, and something faintly magical. Rolling hills of golden grass give way to enormous cylindrical structures—cheese wheels the size of buildings, aging in the afternoon sun. Merchants in colorful aprons scurry between markets displaying wheels, wedges, and strings of enchanted dairy in every conceivable color. A town crier near the central plaza rings a brass bell, announcing the death of Bartholomew Butterworth, the legendary Master of Cheese, whose estate and enchanted cheese collection will be revealed at sunset. Already, you notice three distinct groups eyeing each other suspiciously near the town square.
Description
The party has been hired as "neutral arbiters" (really, they just showed up asking for work) to help manage the inheritance of Bartholomew Butterworth, the wealthiest cheese merchant in Cheese-ia. The hamlet itself is obsessed with cheese—architecture, clothing, daily rituals all revolve around dairy. The three factions vying for the inheritance are: the Gilded Palette (pompous merchants guild), the Goat's Eternal Flame (cultish goat herders with mystical beliefs), and the Ratkins Collective (organized crime family of sapient rats living in the cheese caves below). The will is being read at sunset in Butterworth's estate, a grand mansion made partially of lacquered cheese-curing wood. Environmental storytelling: Scratch marks on the estate's doors suggest repeated break-in attempts; a faint magical shimmer over certain cheese wheels indicates protective enchantments; rat droppings and peculiar goat hair scattered around suggest all three factions have been scouting the location.
DM Notes
This is a setup scene designed for comedy and faction introductions. Allow players to explore Cheddarwood and interact with NPCs. Key skill checks: DC 12 Insight to recognize that the three groups are clearly rivals; DC 13 Investigation to notice the break-in attempts and magical auras on the cheese collection. The Bard may use Deception to learn more from drunk merchants in the tavern (The Melted Wheel). The Rogue can attempt to pickpocket invitations or maps (DC 14 Sleight of Hand). The Paladin's oath might trigger comedy if confronted about the clear criminal intent of the factions. No combat here—focus on roleplay and establishing the absurdist tone. Offer players opportunities to align with one faction or play all sides.
Read Aloud
The sunset paints the estate's lacquered cheese-wood walls in shades of orange and crimson as you file into Butterworth's grand hall. The three factions sit rigidly apart—the Gilded Palette in starched silks, the Goat's Eternal Flame in simple robes bearing mysterious dairy-related symbols, and the Ratkins Collective in tiny suits with comically oversized hats. A nervous-looking halfling notary named Wendell Creamsworth adjusts his spectacles, produces a scroll that unrolls across the entire floor, and begins reading in a trembling voice. "I, Bartholomew Butterworth, being of sound mind and aged palate, do hereby bequeath my enchanted cheese collection to..." He pauses. All three factions lean forward. "...whoever can prove they have the purity of heart most aligned with the True Essence of Cheese." Complete silence. Then chaos erupts.
Description
The will is deliberately vague and magical—Butterworth has bound the inheritance to a magical trial that will unfold over the next few hours. The estate's grand hall contains three sealed chambers, each holding a portion of the legendary collection: The Timeless Wheel (grants immunity to aging magic), The Golden Brie of Binding (can magically seal contracts), and The Sorrow Cheddar (allows the user to sense lies). The will specifies that each faction must complete a "Test of Cheese Worthiness" (which Butterworth never actually defined) to claim their prize. All three factions immediately claim they can pass any test and begin accusing the others of impurity. The Ratkins start surreptitiously moving toward the sealed chambers. The Gilded Palette begins citing obscure cheese-merchant bylaws. The Goat's Eternal Flame begins chanting and burning sage. NPCs present: Wendell Creamsworth (the notary), representatives from each faction (see NPC cards below), and Butterworth's ghost, who may or may not decide to intervene based on player choices.
DM Notes
This scene should erupt into controlled chaos. Let players attempt to mediate, take sides, or steal the cheeses outright. Allow multiple solutions: a Bard could smooth-talk the factions into a temporary truce; a Rogue could pickpocket the chamber keys; a Paladin could demand order via their oath. The three sealed chambers are each protected by basic magical locks (DC 13 Arcana or Thieves' Tools check to bypass, or spell slots of 2nd level or higher). Wendell is spineless and will defer to anyone with authority (Intimidate DC 10). The ghost of Butterworth will appear if any cheese is stolen without his approval, only mildly annoyed. Play up the absurdity: the Ratkins demand "adequate cheese tribute," the Gilded Palette files a formal complaint mid-chaos, and the Goat's Eternal Flame insists that only virgin goats can sense cheese purity. No mandatory combat yet—save that for scene 3 or 4.
Read Aloud
Following a trail of cheese crumbs and tiny rat footprints, you descend into the vast cave system beneath Butterworth's estate. Enormous wheels of aged cheese rest on stone shelves carved into the cavern walls, their surfaces glowing with faint magical auras. Torches flicker with an eerie blue flame. Suddenly, you round a corner and come face to face with Squeaksquire, the leader of the Ratkins Collective, who stands on his hind legs in an oversized velvet coat, flanked by two dozen armed rats wearing tiny leather armor and carrying diminutive crossbows. "Well, well," he squeaks in a surprisingly refined accent, adjusting his monocle. "More cheese-lovers come to claim what is ours by right of rodent heritage. I assume you're not here to negotiate, yes? No? Then perhaps we settle this over a civilized game of Cheese Dice—triple stakes, triple consequences."
Description
The underground vaults are a sprawling network of storage caves where Butterworth kept his most valuable enchanted cheeses. The Ratkins have established a small camp here, with crude furniture made of cheese rinds and tiny furniture scaled for their size. Squeaksquire is a charismatic rat crime lord who would genuinely prefer to avoid violence—he loves a good negotiation, gambling game, or heist plan more than direct combat. However, his pride and his rat cronies' expectations mean he'll fight if disrespected. The caves contain multiple exits, environmental hazards (unstable shelves loaded with massive cheese wheels), and opportunities for creative problem-solving. Key environmental detail: The walls are scarred by previous cave-ins, and certain corners have reinforced wooden bracing—evidence that the Ratkins have been working to stabilize the caves, suggesting they might be planning a long-term occupation, not just a quick theft.
DM Notes
This is a skill challenge and negotiation encounter. Squeaksquire is not evil—he's an opportunist with a sense of honor among thieves. The party can: (1) Gamble with Squeaksquire (DC 13 Deception or Sleight of Hand to cheat; if caught, the Ratkins become hostile); (2) Negotiate a deal to split the inheritance (Persuasion DC 14); (3) Propose a heist against the other two factions instead (Persuasion DC 12); or (4) Combat. If combat triggers, use the Encounter card below. The Ratkins will flee if they lose more than half their number. Squeaksquire himself fights fairly and respects courage—if a PC bests him in single combat, he'll offer an alliance. This scene should feel more like a tense negotiation scene than an outright fight, but combat is absolutely possible.
Read Aloud
You emerge from the cave system to find the Goat's Eternal Flame has set up an enormous bonfire in Butterworth's back garden, where they're performing some sort of ritualistic chant. The cult leader, a wild-eyed woman named Sister Ursula Goatheart, stands before a circle of robed figures, each holding a live goat. She turns to you with unsettling intensity. "The cheeses have SPOKEN! They have chosen US as their rightful custodians! Did you know that Bartholomew Butterworth's soul has been REINCARNATED into the spirit of the SACRED GOAT?" She points to an absolutely ordinary goat that looks mildly confused. "This goat—Lord Cheeseworth Reborn—demands we retrieve the Golden Brie! It is the ONLY path to dairy enlightenment!" The goat bleats. Sister Ursula nods solemnly. "He agrees."
Description
The Goat's Eternal Flame is a small but surprisingly organized cult whose members genuinely believe that cheese is a sacred substance with mystical properties tied to goat spirituality. They're not violent by nature, but they're deeply fanatical and utterly convinced that they alone understand cheese's "true purpose." Sister Ursula is the leader—charismatic, utterly unhinged, and impossible to dissuade from her beliefs. However, she respects "prophetic signs," so a clever PC can potentially convince her that the party's goals align with "the dairy gods' will." The garden contains numerous goats, ritual circles drawn in salt, and an elaborate tent where the cult stores their modest possessions. If the party can convince Sister Ursula that the party members are "chosen by the dairy gods," she will happily grant them access to her faction's resources.
DM Notes
This is entirely a roleplay and social encounter. No combat unless the party attacks first (or is extremely disrespectful). Sister Ursula is delusional but harmless. Key skill checks: Insight (DC 12) to understand that she genuinely believes every word; Religion or Arcana (DC 13) to construct a convincing "prophecy" that aligns with her beliefs; Deception (DC 14) to convince her the party are "emissaries of the dairy gods." The Bard has a natural advantage here. Allow multiple solutions: the party could pretend to join the cult, negotiate a temporary alliance, or simply out-insane Sister Ursula with absurdist logic ("But Sister Ursula, did the goat tell you about the CHEESE WHISPERERS from the Astral Plane?"). If the party succeeds, they can gain access to a secret back entrance into Butterworth's estate.
Read Aloud
You return to the estate's main entrance to find the Gilded Palette merchants conducting a full legal assault on the manor. A portly man in a doublet embroidered with actual gold thread stands atop a gilded ladder, reading from a stack of documents while his associates nail official-looking seals to the estate doors. "By the AUTHORITY vested in the Gilded Palette, Cheese Merchant's Grand Charter, Section 47, Subsection 3.5-delta," he bellows, "this estate is hereby declared a COMMERCIAL HERITAGE SITE, and all contents become the property of the guild for proper STEWARDSHIP and CATALOGING!" He notices you and squints. "Ah! The arbiters! Excellent! You can help us seal the property. We're being VERY legal about this."
Description
The Gilded Palette is the most "civilized" faction—they genuinely believe they're following proper procedure. They've hired a clerk named Thaddeus Goldmeal, who carries a literal suitcase of falsified documents and genuinely believes they're all legitimate. The faction's leader, Lord Merchantus Van Cheddarworth (a distant relative of Bartholomew), is arrogant but not intelligent. He's utterly convinced that legal paperwork can trump magic and inheritance law. The party can: (1) Expose the documents as forgeries (Insight DC 11 or Investigation DC 12); (2) Out-paperwork them with forged counter-documents (Deception DC 15); (3) Challenge them to a formal duel or contest; or (4) Simply refuse and fight if Van Cheddarworth's pride is too wounded. This scene is meant to be comedic—the Gilded Palette are incompetent in a way that's almost endearing.
DM Notes
Thaddeus is the weak link—he's kind-hearted and will immediately crack if someone shows him kindness or points out that Van Cheddarworth is lying (Insight DC 13 or Persuasion DC 12). Van Cheddarworth himself is mostly hot air; if challenged, he'll bluster but back down unless his honor is directly questioned (in which case he'll demand a duel or get his guild to hire mercenaries). Play up the absurdity: the "official seals" are made of wax that says "official seal" on them; the documents are written in perfect calligraphy but literally don't mean anything; one document declares the cheese collection to be "very cheese-like in appearance." If the party wants, they can ally with the Gilded Palette by flattering Van Cheddarworth's intelligence or by helping them "properly catalog" the inheritance.
Read Aloud
As the chaos reaches fever pitch—with the Ratkins emerging from underground, the Goat's Eternal Flame performing protective wards, and the Gilded Palette threatening legal action—the air grows cold. A translucent, rotund figure materializes in the estate's central hall, dressed in an ornate nightcap and cheese-patterned robes. "ENOUGH!" booms the ghost of Bartholomew Butterworth, floating majestically above the crowd. "You're all TERRIBLE! I didn't even like most of you when I was alive!" He drifts down to eye level with the party. "You seem less terrible than the usual suspects. Here's the truth: I didn't actually want ONE faction to get all the cheese. I wanted to see who was clever enough to play all three sides against each other, steal the good stuff, and not get caught. That's REAL cheese mastery—cunning, audacity, and a complete disregard for other people's property."
Description
Butterworth's ghost is genuinely pleased by chaos and trickery. He respects the party if they've been inventive enough to negotiate with multiple factions, and he'll provide them with magical assistance if they're willing to embrace the heist aspect of the situation. The ghost reveals that the three sealed chambers contain far more than just the three legendary cheeses—each chamber has a vault filled with additional magical cheese wheels worth thousands of gold pieces. The ghost also reveals that the "True Essence of Cheese" test was never meant to be a moral evaluation. Butterworth set it up specifically to make the will so vague that the factions would fight amongst themselves, allowing a clever thief to steal everything while they bickered. He's proud of his trickster legacy and wants the party to fulfill his wishes: complete the heist, play the factions against each other, and get away with it all.
DM Notes
This scene pivots the session toward its climax. The ghost is a comedic wild card who will help the party pull off the heist if they ask nicely (or if they amuse him). Butterworth can provide: (1) information about the magical locks on the chambers; (2) ghostly assistance in distracting the factions; (3) advice on how to turn the factions against each other; or (4) a magical artifact to help them escape (a Cheese-Scented Amulet that masks their presence to faction members). Allow the party to decide their next move. If they've already allied with a faction, Butterworth will suggest how to exploit that alliance. If they've been playing all sides, he'll praise their cunning. No mandatory combat here—but the consequences of their choices will play out in Scene 7.
Read Aloud
The three factions are now in open conflict in and around Butterworth's estate. The Ratkins are attempting to tunnel into the sealed chambers from below; the Goat's Eternal Flame is chanting louder and more frantically, their goats running in circles; and the Gilded Palette has given up on paperwork and hired three mercenaries to break down the chamber doors. In the chaos, you have a narrow window to make your move. Butterworth's ghost grins wickedly from above, waiting to see what you do. Will you use the distraction to steal the cheese? Negotiate a four-way split? Start a full-scale war between the factions? The choice is yours, but decide quickly—the mercenaries are ramming the first chamber door, and you can hear the wood splintering from here.
Description
This is the final "heist moment," where the party executes whatever plan they've been developing throughout the session. The scene is designed to accommodate multiple solutions: (1) a direct robbery while the factions are distracted; (2) a negotiated compromise where the party becomes mediators and earns a share; (3) a full combat encounter against the mercenaries and/or faction members; (4) a clever social or magical solution that somehow satisfies all parties; or (5) complete chaos where the party accidentally causes all three factions to unite against them. The three sealed chambers are on the ground floor of the estate, accessible from multiple routes. A Rogue can pickpocket keys; any party member can attempt to brute-force the locks; the party can use magic to break them open; or they can negotiate with one of the factions to provide access. Butterworth's ghost will actively help the party by using his spectral form to distract faction members at key moments.
DM Notes
This is the encounter scene—though it can play out in many ways. If the party goes full heist mode, play up the chaos and use skill checks to resolve conflicts (Stealth, Sleight of Hand, Deception, Persuasion). If they choose combat, reference the encounter card below. If they've allied with a faction, that faction's members will either help them or at least not actively oppose them (depending on the strength of the alliance). Allow creative solutions: a Bard could give an inspiring speech that somehow convinces all parties to cooperate; a Paladin could challenge one faction's leader to single combat for honor; a Rogue could create diversions and pickpocket the keys. The scene should feel dynamic and chaotic—the party is the eye of the storm, making decisions while three factions spiral around them. Play generous with skill checks and reward cleverness over optimization.
Monsters
Tactics
The three mercenaries hired by the Gilded Palette focus on breaking down the sealed chamber doors, using their axes to splinter wood (Armor Class 15, 20 HP per door). They're not particularly skilled fighters—they're essentially vandals with weapons. If attacked, they prioritize self-preservation over loyalty to Van Cheddarworth and will flee if reduced to 5 HP or fewer. The Ratkin Warriors attack with coordinated tactics, attempting to flank targets and use their small size to avoid melee (they dart in and out, making hit-and-run attacks). They carry tiny crossbows dealing 1d6 piercing damage at range and rapiers (1d4 piercing) in melee. The Goatherds are fanatical but poorly trained—they attack with improvised weapons (clubs, staves) and attempt to grapple targets, shouting cultist slogans. Squeaksquire will join combat if his warriors are losing but will parley if his side is losing badly. Sister Ursula will not directly participate but will use the chaos as cover for her own attempts to access the cheeses. Van Cheddarworth will hide behind his mercenaries and hurl insults.
Terrain
Butterworth's estate interior has narrow corridors (15 feet wide), multiple doorways, and two grand staircases. The sealed chambers are on the ground floor behind reinforced doors (see above). There are bookshelves, fine furniture, and decorative cheese wheels scattered about—these provide half-cover and can be overturned as an action to create difficult terrain. The floors are polished and slightly slippery (if a creature is knocked prone, it requires 10 extra feet of movement to stand up again). Multiple windows overlook the back garden, where the Goat's Eternal Flame's bonfire rages, casting eerie shadows. Butterworth's ghost will intervene occasionally to protect the party (canceling one attack against them as a free action once per round) if they've earned his approval.
A wedge of enchanted cheese the size of a shield. When consumed (requires 1 hour of eating), the consumer is protected from aging magic and time-based curses for 1 month. Worth 800 gp to a collector; 300 gp to a basic merchant.
A perfectly spherical ball of pale cheese wreathed in faint golden magic. This cheese can be used to magically seal contracts or agreements—any creature who breaks a promise made while holding this cheese suffers a -2 penalty to all rolls for 7 days. Worth 950 gp to a collector; 200 gp as mundane cheese.
A wheel of aged cheddar that radiates profound melancholy when touched. The wielder can cast Detect Thoughts once per day without expending a spell slot. Worth 850 gp to a collector; 150 gp to someone who doesn't realize it's magic.
Five smaller wheels of magical cheese with lesser enchantments: Cheese of Inspiration (grants advantage on Performance checks for 8 hours), Cheese of Stoicism (advantage on Wisdom saves for 1 hour), Aged Remembrance Cheese (allows the consumer to perfectly recall one conversation they've had), Cheese of Hidden Flavor (makes the eater immune to poison for 24 hours), and Whispering Gouda (allows the eater to speak with animals for 1 hour). Collectively worth 2,200 gp.
A leather-bound journal containing decades of Butterworth's notes on magical cheese cultivation. A scholar would pay 500 gp for this book. If studied for 8 hours, it grants proficiency in the Alchemist's Supplies for anyone who reads it.
A delicate, beautifully crafted knife used for cutting enchanted cheese. Functions as a +1 dagger that deals an additional 1d4 necrotic damage when used against creatures that derive power from food (undead, constructs, aberrations). Worth 400 gp as a magic item, 150 gp as a mundane ceremonial knife.
Story Hooks
The three enchanted cheeses are valuable far beyond Cheese-ia—word of their existence could attract a rogue mage or curator of magical artifacts who will pursue the party for months. If the party negotiates peace between the factions, they've created a political alliance that owes them favors in future adventures. Butterworth's ghost, if satisfied with the party's handling of his wishes, could become a recurring spectral contact who provides advice in exchange for stories of their exploits. The ledger is worth enough that scholars, wizards, and thieves might seek it out. Additionally, one of the five magical cheeses (determined randomly or by DM choice) could have a hidden curse or side effect—for example, the Cheese of Inspiration might make the user compulsively truthful, or the Cheese of Stoicism might make the user emotionless. The discovery of this side effect could lead to a follow-up adventure.
Conclusion
Wrap Up
Whether the party chose to negotiate, heist, or fight their way to victory, they've successfully claimed at least some portion of Butterworth's enchanted cheese collection. The three factions are left bickering in the estate—Van Cheddarworth is filing more "official complaints," Sister Ursula is convinced the party are "dairy angels," and Squeaksquire is grudgingly respecting their cunning. Butterworth's ghost fades with a satisfied chuckle, pleased that his trickery worked out as intended. Wendell Creamsworth, relieved that nobody was permanently killed, officially signs over whatever portions of the inheritance the party claims, using his notarial authority. The townspeople of Cheddarwood are abuzz with stories of the heist, and the party departs with their magical cheese, newfound allies or enemies, and the distinct smell of aged dairy clinging to their belongings.
Cliffhanger
As the party prepares to leave Cheese-ia, a hooded figure intercepts them on the road. They reveal themselves to be an agent of the Planar Cheese Syndicate—a secret organization that believes Butterworth's enchanted cheeses are fragments of a legendary artifact called the Wheel of Eternal Binding that, when reassembled, can magically compel the truth from anyone in the multiverse. The agent offers the party a choice: sell them the cheeses and disappear with a fortune, or keep the cheeses and expect the Syndicate to pursue them across planes until they have what they want.
Next Session Hooks
- The Planar Cheese Syndicate pursues the party across multiple planes of existence, leading to a globe-trotting adventure in search of the other fragments of the Wheel of Eternal Binding.
- One of the magical cheeses begins to 'wake up' or manifest sentience, causing chaos and attracting the attention of a rogue mage who wants to harvest its essence.
- Sister Ursula contacts the party with a vision that another enchanted cheese has been discovered in a distant dungeon, and she begs for the party's aid in retrieving it before the Gilded Palette does.
- Squeaksquire contacts the party with a lucrative heist opportunity in the nearby city-state of Cheddarstone, offering them a percentage of the take if they help the Ratkins pull off a job.
- A scholar or archivist seeks out the party, revealing that Butterworth's ledger contains clues to the location of an entire library of magical cheeses hidden by an ancient civilisation of dairy cultists.
Want to create your own?
Create your own session